Complete Idiot’s Guide Versus Dummies for Music Theory
I have been, or can be if you click on a link and make a purchase, compensated via a cash payment, gift, or something else of value for writing this post. Regardless, I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers.
Music is something that is near and dear to my heart. From fifth grade through eleventh and then for 3 and a half years of college, I was in piano lessons. During graduate school and for pockets of time afterwards, I put those skills and meager talent to use in music ministry. But, I’ve always felt like I was lacking some of the knowledge that would make me a better musician.
So, I was thrilled to receive this last set of books for comparison.
The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Music Theory, written by Michael Miller, is in it’s second edition. Music Theory for Dummies, penned by the duo of Michael Pilhofer and Holly Day, appears to be a first edition.
There are many ways in which these books are similar.
Both titles are written by individuals holding a music degree who have also worked as musicians for a number of years. So, they went beyond the academic and into application. Mr. Pilhofer does hold a Masters degree and is engaged in teaching at the college level whereas as Mr. Miller has dedicated a fair amount of time to writing (with over 60 nonfiction books in his resume.)
Both books come with a CD to give an audio component to a topic that is, after all, largely about sound. The books list the contents of their CD by track. Comparing the two, the Complete Idiot’s Guide appears to have more of a ear training focus than the Dummies book.
Glancing through the table of contents, there is not an appreciable difference in the ultimate goal…being able to put music theory into practice. Both titles seek to form a sold base when it comes to theory with chapters covering how to write your own music by implementing that knowledge.
Here’s the sequence of material in the Complete Idiot’s Guide to Music Theory:
- Tones
- Rhythms
- Tunes
- Accompanying
- Embellishing
- Arranging
Music Theory for Dummies takes you through the material in this order:
- Rhythm:Keeping the Beat
- Melody: The Part You Hum
- Harmony: Fleshing it Out
- Form: How It’s Shaped
- The Part of Tens (fun lists)
While the Dummies book has catchier topic titles, I have to say that I was drawn a bit more to the Complete Idiot’s Guide. During my many years of piano instruction, there was no real emphasis on training my ear when compared to the technical details of hitting the correct note based on reading the music and then getting the right tempo. Yes, I can tell when something is wrong as I can look at the page of music and ‘hear’ it in my head. But, I can NOT easily listen to something and then find the correct notes on the keyboard.
I will add that either of these books present the material in a more friendly manner than some music instruction books. I plan to have the boys read these books as they learn to play, especially P who is an older beginning student. And, I am going to be relearning some ‘forgotten’ (aka misfiled in my brain)information that should help to make me a better accompanist at church as well as learning some of the skills that never were taught during those years of lessons.
The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Music Theory retails for $19.95 ($22 CAN) while Music Theory for Dummies retails for $24.99 ($29.99 CAN.) The lower cost plus a slightly larger book size for the Complete Idiot’s Guide would most likely sway my purchasing decision that way.
Disclaimer ~ I was provided with copies of both books for the purpose of doing a comparison review. No other compensation was provided and the opinions expressed are my own.

hey there and thanks for your information ? I’ve certainly picked up anything new from right here. I did on the other hand expertise several technical issues using this site, since I skilled to reload the site many instances previous to I may just get it to load properly. I were pondering in case your web host is OK? No longer that I am complaining, however slow loading cases instances will often affect your placement in google and could damage your high quality ranking if ads and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and could look out for a lot extra of your respective exciting content. Make sure you update this again very soon..
I have been taking piano lessons for the last year. I took lessons for about 8 years when I was younger, but once I graduated high school I stopped. Huge mistake. I also played other instruments in middle school/high school. I never learned a lot of theory. My current teacher is working with me on that, but I want to learn more. I’ve been looking at both these books (plus a few others) so I just wanted to pop in and thank you for your honest review! 😉
Lisa,
You are welcome. I can say from experience that those breaks in lessons/ practicing make a HUGE difference.
I can see your point about playing by ear vs. reading the music, but I took piano lessons for several years and it took me forever to figure out why I seemed to struggle more than certain friends of mine when learning a new song. I now know that I play by ear – explaining the mystery I puzzled over when I was younger and could not, for the life of me, play a song until I’d heard it at least once. I wanted so much to sit down with a sheet of music and know how to play it, but I couldn’t play a single bar if someone else didn’t play it for me first. So, while you understand the difficulty of not being able to play without sheet music, I must say it’s equally frustrating when you still can’t play with one.
Emily, I can definitely see how frustrating that would be. I was thinking more about how you need a balance of learning to play by reading the music and being able to ‘find’ notes by ear. What really frustrates me is knowing how something is supposed to sound and feeling like there’s a disconnect between my brain and fingers (or vocal chords for that matter.)